Emmy Squared Pizza: Athens

Emmy Squared Pizza on Prince Avenue brings Detroit style pizza to Athens, and the result is one of the best pizza experiences in the city. With nearly 490 reviews at 4.7 stars, the Athens location has earned a loyal following among pizza lovers who appreciate the distinctive style: thick, airy crust baked in a blue steel pan with caramelized cheese edges that shatter and crunch. The pizza menu goes beyond the Detroit style signature to include a range of specialty pies, alongside craveable bites, salads, and a full bar with cocktails and craft beer. Happy hour Monday through Thursday from 4 to 6 PM provides an accessible entry point for people who want to try the pizza at a lower price. The quality of the dough is the foundation. The Detroit style requires a specific hydration and fermentation process that produces a light, pillowy interior with a crispy exterior. Emmy Squared handles this technique well, and the toppings are balanced to complement rather than overwhelm the crust. The Colony is a signature pie that regulars keep ordering. The Prince Avenue location places Emmy Squared in the corridor between downtown and Normaltown. The space is modern and comfortable, with a bar area that adds social energy to the dining room. Emmy Squared is open for lunch and dinner daily. The restaurant takes reservations and also handles walk ins when space is available.